Because this also deserves a post.

[cheesey-taters.livejournal.com]

I absolutely loved this scene in Sunday! Also to everyone who replied in the previous post I made, I added you all as friends. I hope you don't mind!

And now, a bit of getting to know one another on an SGA level. Tell me your:

Favorite Character:
Favorite Pairing:
Favorite Episode/Story Arc:
Least Favorite Character:
Least Favorite Pairing:
Least Favorite Episode/Story Arc:

I'll go first!

Favorite Character: It's a toss up between John Sheppard and Rodney McKay. I generally don't think of them as separate characters, because they've always just been McShep to me, but for the sake of this little questionnaire, I'll say John Sheppard. And that was chosen by a rousing game of Eenie Meenie Miney Mo.
Favorite Pairing: McShep, hands down, with Teyla/Ronon as a close second.
Favorite Episode/Story Arc: Doppelganger, for the simple reason that dark!John is incredibly hot.
Least Favorite Character: Kanaan, just because he was a big part of the end of Season 4 story arc that I hated.
Least Favorite Pairing: It's a tie between Teyla/Kanaan and McKeller.
Least  Favorite Episode/Story Arc: The Teyla-goes-missing arc at the end of S4. I understand they needed something for her character because the actress was pregnant, but it was horrible. They should have just sent her to mainland for a 9 month long party with the Athosians or something.

Comments

[cheesey-taters.livejournal.com]

Sorry if posting least favorite stuff was a no-no here. If it's wrong, that's my bad because I started it!

Also: I'm curious to know what you thought John did that was OOC!

[sgamadison.livejournal.com]

I don't know that it is a no-no. I think this is a place for honest fun and discussion of the show we love, without bashing each other's opinions or preferences.

The user info indicates that it is also open for discussion as to what we'd like to have seen, what bothered us, what we would have done had we been in the director's chair. So I think it is fair to say that your post fits that criteria nicely.

As for the OOC John moment, I thought his reaction to Teyla being pregnant was very CaveMan and the degree of anger and unreasonableness he showed out of character. Enough people pointed out that he probably was reacting after the fact to the potential for serious injury on the last mission that I began to see their POV.

In fact, I came around to the idea that as someone who prided himself as a tactician, John *would* have been pissed at not having all the available information at his disposal. ;-)

[x-varda-x.livejournal.com]

Yeah, I removed my 'least' ones because I swing towards to unpopular in the fandom: I don't like McKay/Sheppard, but I like McKay/Keller. Most people have already said the opposite so this place holds no squee for me.